THE EURO-MEDITERRANEAN MID-TERM MEETING OF
FOREIGN MINISTERS
Crete, 26-27 May 2003
Presidency Conclusions
1. The mid-term Euro-Mediterranean Foreign Ministers'
meeting took place at a crucial time for the development of the
EU, for the EU's relations with its Mediterranean partners and for
the future of the Mediterranean region. The purpose of the meeting
was twofold:
o to take stock of the progress made in the Partnership, particularly
in the implementation of the Valencia Action plan; and
o to discuss its future development, notably in the light of the
future enlargement of the Union. A substantial change occurred following
enlargement since the membership of the partnership grew from 27
to 35.partners The Commission has proposed the establishment of
a new EU neighbourhood framework as set out in its Communication
on 'Wider Europe - neighbourhood'. The Ministers discussed the role
of the Mediterranean partners on the basis of this proposal.
2. The Ministers expressed their deep sorrow, sincere
sympathy and full support to the Algerian government and people
alike for the unspeakable human and material losses caused by the
last earthquake's catastrophe. The Ministers expressed their full
solidarity to the Algerian government and their governments' readiness
to assist the Algerian people in every possible manner. After the
recent disasters in Turkey and Algeria, the partners should examine
the possibilities for further cooperation in facing and reacting
to earthquakes in the region, using inter alia the experience acquired
through the Euromediterranean pilot project on the prevention and
mitigation of natural and man-made disasters.
3. The Ministers also expressed their full solidarity
with Morocco which was hit on May 16 by terrorist attacks. These
abhorrent acts can only reinforce their will to strengthen international
cooperation to fight against terrorism.
4. The Ministers discussed the recent developments
in the Middle East and the Mediterranean. Violence, destruction,
suffering, human rights violations and bloodshed have continued
in the region, reaching again an alarming level during the last
weeks. They expressed their condemnation of terrorism, violence
and deplored the loss of human lives and extended their deepest
sympathy to the families of those killed and wounded.
5. They expressed also their concern and eagerness
to confront violence and hatred by addressing the very causes of
violence, terrorism and dehumanisation in Mediterranean societies.
There is an urgent need to go further than condemning terrorism,
violence and human rights violations and to promote all those initiatives,
and programs, which can be premises of dialogue, conflict prevention
and regional co-operation and development.
6. The Ministers unequivocally reiterated their
support for peaceful means of conflict resolution in the region.
Peace in the Middle East should be restored on the basis of UNSCR
242, 338 and 1397. The Peace Process should lead to the creation
of a democratic, viable and independent State of Palestine, bringing
to an end the occupation of 1967, and the right of Israel to live
within secure and recognised boundaries, guaranteed by the commitment
of the international community. The end of the conflict requires
agreed solutions to all aspects of permanent status issues.
7. Comprehensive peace must also include Syria
and Lebanon on the basis of the above mentioned UN Security Council
Resolutions and the Arab Peace initiative.
8. The Road Map adopted by the Quartet is a great
opportunity to bring back substantial peace negotiations, which
should not be missed. It is now for the leaderships to shoulder
their responsibilities towards their nations and towards the future
of the region.
9. The Ministers warmly welcomed the decision of
the Palestinian Authority and Prime Minister Mahmoud Abbas to adopt
the Road Map. They were equally convinced that the Road Map serves
the interest of the Israeli people to live in security and in this
context, they welcomed the acceptance by Prime Minister Sharon and
the Government of Israel on 25 May 2003. This was considered to
be an important and positive step forward. The Ministers called
on both parties to take advantage of this window of opportunity
and proceed with the faithful and effective implementation of the
Road Map without delay. Confidence building measures including a
credible Quartet monitoring mechanism are a salient feature of the
effort to rejuvenate the Peace Process.
10. It is most probable that extremist groups will
target the Road Map trying to derail it and bring havoc to the region.
Both parties must show ultimate restraint and refrain from actions
that can inflame hatred and play into the hands of the extremists,
jeopardising a most delicate process to open the horizon for a peaceful
solution.
11. The Ministers called on the international community
and the regional states to preserve, strengthen and assist the Palestinian
Authority's efforts to rebuild its infrastructure, security and
governance capacity in order to fight terrorism and uproot poverty
and deprivation.
12. The Ministers reiterated that the Middle East
Peace Process and the Barcelona Process are complementary, and expressed
their readiness to use fully the potential of the Barcelona Process
to make a positive contribution to the stabilisation of the Mediterranean
region. At the present juncture, a reinvigorated cooperation within
the region and with Mediterranean partners should be sought.
13. The Ministers discussed also the issue of Iraq
and expressed their concern to safeguard the unity, territorial
integrity and sovereignty of the country and stability in the region.
They called upon the international community and regional states
to work closely with the UN to this end. It is also imperative that
the Iraqi people decide their political future and manage the country's
natural resources for their own benefit.
14. In this framework the Ministers welcomed the
UNSCR 1483/2003 on Iraq as a clear sign of a new spirit of co-operation
within the international community. They also welcomed the Resolution's
provisions for a key UN role in the rebuilding effort in this country
and the nomination of Sergio Vieira de Mello as the UN Special Representative
for Iraq, with whom they look forward to working closely in order
to address the immediate needs of the Iraqi people. It will also
provide for a legitimate Iraqi interim administration and mobilize
support of the international community, as it will enhance international
co-ordination for rallying support for the political and economic
reconstruction process.
Association Agreements
15. The Valencia Action Plan, agreed unanimously
by the participants at the Valencia meeting, contains a series of
activities to reinforce all areas of the Partnership. The Ministers
acknowledged that good progress has been made on many of them. Association
Agreements are now in force with Tunisia, Morocco, Israel, and Jordan
and on an interim basis with the Palestinian Authority and Lebanon.
16. The Association process remains at the core
of the Partnership. The Ministers encouraged EU Member States to
speed up the ratification process of Agreements not yet in force
with Egypt, Algeria and Lebanon; the Ministers recognised that the
conclusion of interim agreements and other measures to advance implementation
of relevant commitments under the Agreements would be a welcome
sign. The Ministers welcomed progress made in many areas on the
implementation of the Agreements in force notably the regular holding
of Association Councils and Committees as well as the setting up
of sub-Committees such as under the Agreement with Morocco, which
should serve, with any necessary adaptations, as a model for the
other Agreements in force. They reaffirmed the importance of completing
the grid of Euromediterranean Association Agreements by concluding
the negotiations with Syria.
17. The EU Presidency welcomed the Libyan delegation
to the Ministerial Conference. Taking into account Libya's role
in the Mediterranean region and the African continent, the EU Presidency
believes that Libya could positively contribute to the strengthening
of the Euromediterranean cooperation. The Presidency also welcomed
the presence of other special guests of the Presidency: the Arab
League, the UMA and Mauritania.
Political and Security Partnership
Political and security dialogue
18. The Ministers took note of the ongoing efforts
to enhance the political and security dialogue and reiterated the
importance of the Barcelona Process, underlined by SG/HR Solana
who participated at a Senior Officials meeting on 3 February 2003.
The Ministers restated the commitment of all to the aims and principles
of the Partnership, and took note of work accomplished so far as
regards the assessment of the state of play of the security and
political dialogue ; they invited Senior Officials to continue focusing
on the following:
- effective dialogue on security matters in particular the dialogue
on ESDP, through the establishment of liaisons with the new structures
developed by the Union,
- dialogue on root causes of instability,
- development of preventive diplomacy mechanisms exploring possibilities
of cooperation on conflict prevention with a special emphasis on
crisis management,
- continue to promote non proliferation of WMD and adherence to
multilateral instruments on arms control,
- the fight against terrorism,
- improvement of the working methods i.a. through the holding of
thematic meetings,
- pursue the effort to identify common ground for cooperation among
all partners through subregional cooperation which should be particularly
encouraged in order to allow for the gradual establishment of a
common space of peace and stability while ensuring the consolidation
of the commitments undertaken by all partners in this field. They
specified that co-operation should be developed with those most
willing, on a non-exclusive basis, with others welcome to join at
a later stage.
Partnership building measures
19. The Ministers encouraged the consolidation
of the existing PBMs and invited partners to submit new initiatives.
The assessment of the pilot project on mitigation of natural or
man-made disasters was recalled; the positive contribution of the
Euromesco network of Foreign Policy Institutes was recalled. The
positive role of the Malta seminars for bringing together diplomats
of the region and deepening the partnership was acknowledged; The
Ministers also welcomed ongoing efforts for the activation of the
Register of treaties among partners and encouraged them to be further
pursued.
20. With regard to the Euro-Mediterranean Charter
for Peace and Stability, the Ministers reconfirmed the mandate of
the Senior Officials so that they can continue their work to enable
the Charter to be adopted as soon as the political situation allows.
Fight against terrorism
21. The Ministers reiterated their will, once more,
to continue and step up the fight against terrorism in full respect
of international law, human rights, fundamental freedoms and the
rule of law. They stressed that the fight against terrorism should
be a regular subject in the political dialogue between partners.
They underlined the need to combat the scourge of terrorism as a
global challenge in all its forms whatever its motives or aims and
reconfirmed the intention to intensify cooperation in all competent
international fora. In that framework a proposal to convene an International
Conference was recalled. Differences regarding the definition of
terrorism should not prevent partners from identifying areas where
they can cooperate. The Ministers welcomed the contribution of regional
efforts to combat terrorism and underlined the importance of a regional
response to this challenge. Such efforts were welcomed as particularly
useful in the context of the UN discussions aiming at a Comprehensive
Convention on Terrorism.
22. The Ministers welcomed the possibility of Senior
Officials holding a further Ad hoc meeting on this issue before
the next Ministerial to be held in Naples, in order to enhance cooperation
on this important subject.
Human rights and democracy
23. The Ministers recognised the necessity of allowing
for an open discussion of issues related to human rights and democracy.
They welcomed the effort to identify areas of common ground for
co-operation in legislative and regulatory reform as well as implementation
of such reforms and establish a jointly agreed course of action
in line with the Communication on 'Wider Europe'. They took note
of a presentation by the Commission of its Communication "Reinvigorating
EU actions on Human rights with Mediterranean partners" and
agreed on the need to examine the issues outlined in the Communication
in the framework of the Euromediterranean Partnership's structures.
24. The Ministers recognised the need for improvement
of the dialogue on this subject and invited Senior Officials to
look for complementary ways in order to improve co-operation in
these fields.
Euro-Mediterranean Parliamentary Assembly
25. The Ministers agreed to include the envisaged
Parliamentary Assembly, of a consultative capacity, in the framework
of the Barcelona Process once the European Parliament and Euromediterranean
national Parliaments will have reached agreement on its creation.
In that respect they expressed their hope that the European Parliament
and the Euro-Mediterranean national parliaments will reach this
agreement. Ministers also agreed that the transformation of the
Euromed Parliamentary forum to a Euromed Parliamentary Assembly
would be a positive development that will strengthen the parliamentary
dimension of the Euromed Partnership and the Barcelona Process.
Economic and Financial Partnership
26. The Ministers recognised that while there are
a number of positive elements in the overall macro-economic situation
of the countries of the region (stabilisation of inflation, fiscal
deficits, balance of payments), the economic growth performance
has proved to be insufficient to accommodate a rapidly expanding
labour force and raise living standards. They noted the conclusions
of the seminar on economic transition, which was held on 23-24 April
in Brussels. The Association Agreements with the EU can provide
an "anchor" that reinforces the commitment to reforms
and enhances the credibility and prospects of the reform process.
They acknowledged that the establishment of a Free Trade Area through
import tariff dismantling generates an impulse to enhance competitiveness
in partners' industries through "mise à niveau"
programmes for individual enterprises as well as general reforms
at the level of public policies and institutions.
Efforts to improve the qualifications of the labour force are necessary
to boost productivity.
27. The Ministers recognised that tariff dismantling
is proceeding in accordance with commitments and is now having a
significant impact in countries where it is affecting tariffs that
protect domestic industries. They acknowledged that this reinforces
the need for economic reforms, and recognised that there remains
unexploited potential in the Association Agreements and in MEDA
co-operation to accompany this process.
28. They stressed that all opportunities should
be taken to further promote relations between the Mediterranean
partners and the acceding countries to ensure that, upon enlargement
of the EU, the Euro-Mediterranean partnership will be reinforced
by this expansion.
South-South trade and Integration
29. As regards South-South trade and integration
the Ministers welcomed the initialling of the Agadir Agreement providing
for free trade between Morocco, Tunisia, Jordan and Egypt by 2006
and for the implementation of which the Commission will provide
technical support. They underlined the importance they attach to
the development of sub-regional integration. The issue should be
studied jointly with a view to reach operational conclusions at
the earliest, inter alia on enhancing cooperation in the Maghreb,
the Mashrek, or on any other basis. They recognised significant
progress made on the implementation of pan-Euro-Mediterranean cumulation
of origin following the objectives set by the Euromed Trade Ministers
in Toledo in 2002. They welcomed proposals on trade facilitation
discussed by the working group on regional integration. On one hand,
these concern simplification, harmonisation and computerisation
of customs procedures and on the other approximation of standards
and technical Regulations: The Ministers underlined the importance
of further liberalisation in the services sector. They welcomed
the implementation of the Euro-Med Market programme permitting closer
regulatory and legislative approximation of the Mediterranean partners
to the EU's Internal Market. They also underlined the importance
of the forthcoming Euromediterranean Ministerial Conference on Trade
in Palermo.
Transport and Energy
30. Infrastructure interconnection is similarly
an important part of regional co-operation. Trans-Euro-Mediterranean
networks need to be developed in energy, transport and telecommunications
starting on a sub-regional basis. The Ministers should welcome the
effective start of the Euromed Transport Project and the resuming
of working group activities in the perspective of the forthcoming
Ministerial Conference in Rome in December 2003. The application
of the Galileo Global Navigation Satellite System to both energy
and transport systems to the Mediterranean is being promoted. New
regional programmes on transport and energy are due to be approved
in the regional financing plan for 2004, which will be a further
step in developing regional and sub-regional transport and energy
strategies and concrete actions for the partners.
31. The Ministers welcomed the outcome of the 3rd
Conference of Energy Ministers (Athens, 20-21 May). They expressed
satisfaction with the Presidency's intention to apply the principle
of co-chairmanship foreseen in the Valencia Action Plan during this
Conference. They welcomed the Declaration adopted by the Conference,
which recalls the central role of the Energy sector in the achievement
of the objectives of the Barcelona Process and outlines the priorities
of the relevant regional cooperation between 2003 and 2006. These
priorities focus on the promotion and development of the Trans-Euro-Mediterranean
Energy Networks, the security of supply, the promotion of renewable
sources of Energy as well as the safety, security and financing
of energy infrastructures.. On the basis of these results and the
subsequent work, they strongly encouraged the regional and sub-regional
development of energy infrastructure inter-connection (gas, electricity
and oil), energy policy reforms and the emergence of a Maghreb electricity
market, through co-operation between MEDA, the EIB, the IFIs and
the Mediterranean Partners and Member States' national programmes.
They welcomed the important initiative of Israel and the Palestinian
Authority to cooperate in the framework of a Technical Working Group
open to other Mediterranean Partners with a view to identifying
and promoting inter-connexion projects of common interest to be
integrated into the framework of the Euromediterranean partnership.
FEMIP and Investment
32. The Ministers welcomed the setting up of the
Facility for Euro-Mediterranean Investment and Partnership (FEMIP),
launched in Barcelona in October 2002. They noted the results of
the meeting of the Policy Dialogue and Coordination Committee (PDCC)
that took place in Istanbul on 3 April 2003. They recalled that
an evaluation of the functioning of FEMIP will be submitted, on
the basis of which a decision should be taken later this year to
determine the future course of action on the Facility and on the
incorporation of an EIB majority owned subsidiary dedicated to the
Mediterranean Partner Countries.
33. The EIB has committed the necessary staff and
financial resources to translate commitments into action, most of
them operational as of the end of 2002, including in particular
a focus on private sector development. A new regional office is
due to be opened in Cairo by July 2003 and the opening of further
offices in the region is foreseen later in 2003. The Bank's activities
stood at around € 1.5 billion in 2002 and should reach an annual
total of some € 2 billion by 2006.
34. The Ministers recognised that while the major
effort to improve the region's attractiveness to investors needs
to come from the partners themselves, the EU should explore how
it could further encourage partner countries in this endeavour.
Development of support from FEMIP for private sector development
will be very important. Other measures should be introduced to attract
investment to the region: the Commission is prepared to arrange
a meeting of a Round Table of Industrialists to focus on investment
opportunities in the region. Central Bank Governors could meet to
discuss a potential enhancement of monetary and exchange rate policies
and the implications of the euro for the Mediterranean region.
Financial Co-operation
35. The Ministers welcomed the substantial improvement
which has now been shown in the implementation of financial co-operation.
For 2002, commitments under MEDA, Turkey having separate legal bases,
amounted to € 611 million and payments to € 451 million
representing a payments/commitments ratio for the year of 72%, compared
to 53 % for 2001 and 26% for the period of MEDA I (1995-99). Taking
all relevant budget lines together the commitments amounted to €
762 million and the payments to € 684 million, i.e. a payments/commitments
ratio of 90%. These improvements reflect inter alia the fact that
the reform of the Commission's External Aid system came fully on
stream during 2002 and EuropeAid became fully operational. Moreover
devolution of the implementation of projects to EU delegations in
the Mediterranean partners is practically complete, leading to both
quantitative and qualitative improvements in the delivery of aid.
The new commitments continue to be principally focussed on programmes
either directly or indirectly linked to the implementation of the
Association Agreements, economic reforms and good governance. The
Ministers encouraged the Commission to continue its efforts to strengthen,
in cooperation with Member States and Partner countries, the coordination
of programmes financed by MEDA, Member States, EIB and international
organisations.
36. EIB loans signed in 2002 amounted to €
1.6 billion with nearly one third in favour of the private sector
and 1 billion euros were disbursed that same year. In the public
sector the main sectors of intervention were in transport and energy,
often with an intra-regional interest, as well as support for the
health and education sectors.
Environment
37. The Ministers also welcomed the outcome of
the Ministerial Conference on the Environment that took place in
Athens in July 2002. By adopting the Athens Declaration the 27 participants
to the Conference provided a significant impetus to the mainstreaming
of sustainability in all activities of the Partnership. A Sustainability
Impact Assessment of the free trade area is to be launched this
year fulfilling the commitment agreed at Valencia. Besides, the
contribution of the Ministerial Conference on the Environment in
Helsinki in 1997 on cooperation between the Mediterranean and the
Baltic and the launching in Athens of the cooperation initiative
on sustainable development between the Mediterranean and the Baltic,
enable the two regions to benefit from each other's experience.
38. The Ministers recognised that work should continue
with a view to identifying what more can be done to enhance the
sustainability of the Partnership and to assist the partners in
raising the standards of norms of environmental protection.
39. The Ministers noted with interest the initiatives
undertaken by the Greek Presidency on the issue of sustainable development
such as the convening of the International Conference on Sustainable
Development and Lasting Peace (Athens, 6/7 May 2003), co-hosted
by the World Bank, as well as the presentation by the Presidency
of the EU Water Initiative.
Social, Cultural and Human Partnership
Justice, fight against organised crime, migration and movement
of people
40. The Ministers recognised that agreement on
the regional programme on justice, combating drugs, organised crime
and terrorism and the social integration of migrants, migration
and the movement of people was a significant achievement of Valencia
which not only allows the regional programme to be launched in June
2003 on a basis that meets the interests of all partners, but also
provides a framework for action at the bilateral level, serving
as an example They had an exchange of views on developing co-operation
regarding in particular practical implementation. The Ministerial
meeting on migration and the social integration of migrants scheduled
for later in the year will represent one opportunity to develop
further a global and balanced approach to the management of migratory
flows and the integration of migrants. This will also have to be
done for judicial co-operation and the fight against organised crime
including terrorism. The Ministers encouraged the promotion, as
far as possible, of bilateral readmission agreements between the
European Union and the Mediterranean Partners and between the Partners
themselves as well as with key source countries, for people in irregular
situations, in accordance with the provisions of public international
law, and, where applicable, with the obligations contained in the
Association Agreements and bilateral Agreements between the Euro-Mediterranean
partners. In this context, they welcomed the recent start of official
negotiations with Morocco.
41. The EU recalled that the necessary steps had
been taken in order to facilitate the issuing of visas to Mediterranean
representatives attending bilateral and multilateral meetings as
part of the Barcelona Process. Some Mediterranean Partners complained
about their inclusion in the list of countries for which a consultation
(up to 14 days) is required for the issuance of Schengen visas.
Dialogue between cultures and civilisations
42. Agreement at Valencia on the Action programme
for the dialogue of cultures and civilisations focusing i.a. on
Youth, Education and Media has been accompanied by a number of actions
in this area. The Ministers underlined the importance of targeting,
whenever appropriate, the younger generations who are the citizens
and decision makers of tomorrow in the activities undertaken in
that framework. They welcomed ongoing activities on the cultural
heritage, audio-visual co-operation and youth exchanges. Following
the agreement last year on the opening of the TEMPUS programme to
the Mediterranean partners, inter-university co-operation projects
and individual mobility grants for teachers and university staff
will be financed for the academic year starting in the autumn of
2003.
43. The Ministers recognised that the dialogue
of cultures and civilisations instituted by the Barcelona Process
is one of the major contributions to bring peoples closer and promote
understanding and improve mutual perceptions. They agreed on guiding
principles between cultures and civilisations annexed to these conclusions.
44. The Ministers also made progress towards agreement
on the Euro-Mediterranean Foundation for the dialogue of cultures
and civilisations. They agreed on its goals, objectives, activities
and establishment, annexed to these conclusions. They invited the
Senior Officials to continue work on issues related to its structure,
functioning as well as financing with a view to agreement at Barcelona
V?. They agreed to take into account the input of the High Level
Group set up by the President of the Commission, to establish the
Foundation.
Role of women
45. The Ministers welcomed the efforts undertaken
in the framework of the Partnership since the Brussels Ministerial
Conference with a view to promote equal opportunities between women
and men. They recalled the need to pursue the efforts to promote
this issue adequately and reinforce the role of women in the economic
life. They welcomed ongoing efforts in view of the launching of
the regional programme on the role of women in economic life.
Visibility of the Partnership
46. The Ministers welcomed the implementation of
the regional programme on information and communication, which will
raise through specific actions the visibility of the Partnership.
The "Euromed Dialogue" by using television and radio to
encourage a dialogue to raise public awareness of news of actions
under the Partnership will also have an important role to play in
improving mutual perceptions between Europe and the partners.
Social consequences of economic transition
47. The Ministers considered ways of addressing
the social consequences of economic transition. The preparation
of the regional programme on "education and training for employment"
should be completed this year, as well as that for enhancing "the
role of women in economic life". The proposals of the UNDP
Arab Human Development Report for co-operation in this chapter of
the Partnership were emphasised. They underlined the importance
of the fight against poverty as a means of addressing instability.
Civil Society
48. The Ministers welcomed the recent convening
of a Civil Forum focusing on the dialogue of cultures and civilisations
in Crete (May 1-4) whose outcome was presented to them by a representative
of the Forum. The Ministers also encouraged the efforts undertaken
to provide continuity between Civil Fora and to better organise
a more structured input from civil society to the official institutions
of the partnership with a view to the Civil Forum to be held prior
to the Naples Foreign Ministers' Meeting. They agreed that these
efforts should however preserve the autonomy of the actors involved
including the organisers and avoid institutionalisation of the role
of participating organisations.
Wider Europe
49. The Ministers discussed the application, in
a concerted manner, of the policy guidelines proposed in the Commission
Communication on Wider Europe to the Mediterranean partners. The
enlargement of the Union offers new opportunities for partnership
and co-operation. They agreed that the proposed new Neighbourhood
Policy sets out a means to reinforce the Barcelona Process, and
to develop closer co-operation based on the mutual recognition of
common interests. The Ministers invited the Commission to explore
how, within the existing MEDA framework, a more substantial involvement
of the Mediterranean partners in the relevant EU programmes could
be achieved. In this respect, regional and sub-regional cooperation
needs specific attention. The Ministers explored how the approach
proposed by the Wider Europe Communication could be used in order
to improve co-operation with the Mediterranean partners, bilaterally
through the Association Agreements and multilaterally through the
Euro-Mediterranean Committee and the Senior Officials' Meeting.
They underlined the need to continue a common reflexion on these
issues.
50. The Ministers noted that the Commission's recent
policy proposals on a "Wider Europe" new neighbourhood
policy are intended to promote this process. This will encourage
regulatory reform, especially in the services sector, that can give
a strong boost to economic growth and competitiveness. The economic
impact of EU Enlargement on the partners should thus not only be
considered in terms of direct trade, investment and other macro-economic
effects but also, and perhaps even more importantly, in terms of
focusing attention on further economic policy reforms that constitute
the driving force behind economic growth performance.
ANNEX 1 - GUIDING PRINCIPLES FOR THE DIALOGUE BETWEEN CULTURES
AND CIVILISATIONS
The Ministers for Foreign Affairs of the Euro-Mediterranean Partnership
countries, meeting in Crete, on 26th and 27th May 2003,
1. recalling the very significant contribution which, throughout
history, peoples of the Mediterranean basin have made to the mutual
enrichment of cultures and civilisations;
2. underlining the importance of the Dialogue between cultures and
civilisations, as well as its role as an instrument to promote a
culture of peace and to achieve mutual understanding, bring peoples
closer, remove the threats to peace and strengthen exchanges among
civilisations;
3. underlining their willingness to deepen the Dialogue between
cultures and civilisations and convinced that the forthcoming enlargement
of the European Union will enrich this Dialogue;
4. reiterating their commitment to the main principles established
by the Barcelona Declaration and in particular, those regarding
the cultural and human dimension of the Euro-Mediterranean process
which constitute a condition for an authentic and balanced partnership,
as was underlined by the Conferences of the Ministers of Culture
of Bologna (April 1996) and of Rhodes(September 1998)and by the
Stockholm Workshop(April 1998) including the need for a better understanding
and for mutual respect between cultures and civilisations;
5. reaffirming the importance stressed by the Euro-Mediterranean
Conference in Valencia of promoting dialogue and cooperation between
cultures and civilisations among all members of the Euro-Mediterranean
Partnership considering that the Mediterranean region is the birth
place of several great civilisations of the history of the world
in which originated the three monotheistic religions;
6. considering that the Euro-Mediterranean Partnership provides
for an essential dialogue, comprising all the major challenges,
of political, economic, social, cultural and human nature, which
affect the destiny of the peoples of the region;
7. reaffirming the principles that should govern the dialogue as
contained in the Action Programme for the Dialogue between Cultures
and Civilisations, adopted in Valencia:
- respect for pluralism, diversity and cultural specificities;
- equality and mutual respect;
- avoidance and reduction of prejudices and stereotypes ;
- the Dialogue should aim to achieve, not only a better understanding
of "the other", but also solutions for persistent problems;
- the ultimate goal of Dialogue, should not be to change "the
other" but, rather, to live peacefully with "the other";
8. considering that each people has its own values, customs, languages
and beliefs that make it unique;
9. stressing that the plurality and diversity of cultures is one
of the most precious assets of the Mediterranean region to be safeguarded
and preserved, as well as all those that constitute the common heritage
of humanity;
10. conscious that the values of dialogue, tolerance and respect
for the Other, which are common to all religions, constitute an
important factor in bringing closer together cultures and civilisations;
11. taking into consideration and acting at all times in accordance
with:
- the purposes and principles of the Charter of the United Nations,
which are, inter alia, to settle disputes by peaceful means and
to develop friendly relations among nations, based on respect for
the principle of equal rights and self-determination of peoples;
- the UN resolution entitled "United Nations Year of Dialogue
among Civilisations", and the UNESCO Universal Declaration
on Cultural Diversity (November 2001) as well as the guidelines
on the cultural and historical heritage as defined by the Bologna
conference in April 1996;
- the conclusions of the Second Euro-Mediterranean Conference of
the Ministers of Culture, held in Rhodes on 25-26 September 1998,
which endorsed the conclusions of the 1998 Stockholm workshop, providing
general guidelines and principles for the Dialogue between cultures
and civilisations;
12. underlining that also regional and local authorities, as well
as other relevant national institutions, can make valuable contributions
to the dialogue between cultures and civilisations through decentralised
cooperation and twinning and need to be closely involved in this
work, which is an essential part of the Euro-Mediterranean Partnership;
13. acknowledging the contribution of the regional programmes (Euro-med
Heritage, Euro-med Audio-visual, Euro-med Youth, Euro-med Tempus)
to the Dialogue between cultures and civilisations;
14. sharing the Olympic ideal of building a peaceful and better
world by educating the youth of the world, through sport, which
requires mutual understanding, promoted by friendship, solidarity
and fair play, and re-affirming the idea of the Olympic Truce;
declare that
15. The Dialogue between cultures and civilisations is an appropriate
instrument to achieve constructive interaction and effective cooperation
among nations; it contributes to mutual understanding; it enriches
our common values; it is an efficient means of conflict prevention
and requires the active participation of civil society, both by
institutions and individuals distinguished in the fields of thought,
culture and society.
16. This Dialogue is part of our daily lives and should become an
important instrument to fight fanaticism of any kind, extremism,
racism and xenophobia.
17. The Dialogue between cultures and civilisations promotes understanding
of other models of society, of ways of thinking and ways of acting
and to co-exist, and favour interaction in a harmonious framework.
18. The Dialogue between cultures and civilisations is a basis for
understanding our common history and opening current avenues of
cooperation, so that freedom, peace and justice may prevail.
19. It is for our states and peoples to engage themselves in an
authentic dialogue between cultures and civilisations that will
foster mutual respect, understanding and trust; efforts to ensure
a rapid economic development of the region should be pursued.
agree
20. To promote knowledge, recognition and mutual respect between
the cultures, traditions and values which prevail in the partners.
21. To help create, in their respective countries, the respect for
each other in a world based on tolerance and acceptance of differences.
22. To encourage, in their respective countries, all relevant institutions
to contribute to the Dialogue between cultures and civilisations
and in particular to support cooperation, inter alia, in the field
of Youth, Education and the Media.
23. To encourage initiatives which aim at promoting dialogue between
religions in the Euro-Mediterranean region.
24. To promote at the same time the human dimension of the partnership
as well as the consolidation of the rule of law and of basic freedoms
in accordance with the guidelines of the regional cooperation programme
which was also adopted in this field by the Valencia Conference
(April 2002).
25. To underline the decisive role in the implementation of the
above mentioned actions of the Euro-Mediterranean Foundation for
Dialogue of Cultures and Civilisations, the principle of which was
agreed in Valencia and whose goals, objectives, and fields of activity
were adopted in Crete, while the modalities of its establishment
will be submitted at the next Euro-Mediterranean Conference in Naples
in December 2003 (Barcelona VI).
26. To underline the vital importance of ensuring that all partners
encourage the development and deepening of the cultural and human
dimension of the Euro-Mediterranean partnership in all its aspects
and its various components at bilateral or multilateral level.
ANNEX 2 - EURO-MEDITERRANEAN FOUNDATION ON A DIALOGUE OF
CULTURES
PREAMBLE
a) The 1995 Barcelona Declaration states the need, in chapter III,
to develop a dialogue of cultures and civilisations within the framework
of the Mediterranean societies. The Action Plan adopted at the most
recent ministerial meeting at Valencia includes a mandate for the
setting up of a Euro-Mediterranean Foundation for a dialogue of
cultures and civilisations.
b) The establishment of this new intergovernmental instrument within
the framework of the Barcelona Process is a priority, for the following
reasons:
- in the first place, on account of the need, in this essential
sphere, for a dynamic structure, which should contribute decisively
to the development of a true sense of joint ownership of the Barcelona
Process by its members.
- the importance of having an instrument that would disseminate
the goals of the Barcelona Process and its development amongst the
European and Mediterranean societies. Therefore, the implementation
of Chapter III of the Barcelona Process requires actions whose objective
is to reach the greatest possible number of citizens, while aspiring
to overcome barriers in the way of access to information and to
achieve a greater level of mutual knowledge between them;
- the need to set up an institution that, in the cultural field,
is able to promote the coherent identification and execution of
projects that are relevant to the dialogue of cultures and increased
cultural co-operation;
- the need to set up an institution that catalyses and provides
an inventory of co-operation between the existing networks of foundations,
NGOs and other institutions of civil society, whether public or
private, national or international, which operate in the Euro-Mediterranean
area.
1. Goals and Objectives
The objectives shall be established as set out in the statutes of
the Foundation which will be proposed to the institutions of the
Euro-Mediterranean partnership. The main objectives are:
- to identify, develop and promote areas of cultural convergence
between the countries and peoples of the Mediterranean, with the
aim in particular of avoiding stereotypes,
- to hold a close and regular dialogue between cultural circles
often kept outside the main diplomatic and cultural exchanges,
- to serve as a catalyst for promoting exchanges, co-operation and
mobility between people at all levels, targeting in particular the
young and activities relevant to young people.
2. Activities
In the framework of these main objectives the activities of the
Foundation should take into account existing achievements within
and beyond the Euro-Mediterranen Partnership, thus avoiding any
duplication of effort. The activities should also be in line with
the non governmental nature of the Foundation.
The areas of heritage, audio-visual information technology, professional
training, to name but a few, are to a large extent already covered
by the Euro-Mediterranean regional programmes (Euromed Heritage,
Euromed Audiovisuel, Eumedis, Euromed Jeunesse, etc).
Similarly, many government and non-governmental agencies (Associations,
Foundations, Cultural Centres, Festivals, etc) are already active
in the cultural field. Existing activities or entities should not
be duplicated or financed ; instead the Foundation should bring
its own added value to activities. In that respect lessons should
be learned from the old decentralised co-operation programmes (Med
Media, Med Campus, etc) and existing regional programmes (Euromed
Heritage, Euromed Audiovisuel).
In this framework the following types of activities should be agreed
for the Foundation :
- exchanges between cultural and intellectual circles in the wider
sense,
- promoting a continuous cultural debate using in particular multi-media
techniques (television, radio, periodical magazine, Internet) in
co-operation with important existing media and with the participation
of people from both shores including journalists and the young ,
- patronage of important events which symbolise mutual understanding
(for example, a limited number of concerts, exhibitions, etc on
relevant themes), co-financed by large media groups and/or festivals
and institutions already active in these areas,
- promoting the activities of the Barcelona Process including through
means of the Foundation itself (periodical magazine, Internet site).
In this spirit, an indicative list of possible activities is annexed
hereto. It is to be noted that the discussion on the objectives
and activities of the Foundation should also take into account the
results of the work of the High Level Advisory Group set up by Commission
President Romano Prodi.
3. Establishment
a) The Foundation will be created through a step by step procedure.
At least in the initial stage, it will function as a network of
networks. There will be a light independent administrative structure
which will be responsible for the coordination of the network of
national networks.
b) Each country will identify appropriate institutions and organisms
that at national level are working to develop a dialogue of cultures
and civilisations within the framework of the Euro-Mediterranean
societies and will select the institution/organism that will play
the role of head of the national network;
c) The Foundation would play a pivotal role in mobilising the relevant
networks existing within the EU and in its Mediterranean partners
dealing with the dialogue of cultures and civilisations. It would
assist members of the network in securing access to funding, bring
people and organisations together, spreading knowledge and sharing
best practice with the aim of furthering the dialogue on cultures
and civilisations.
d) Since linkage of the Foundation to the Barcelona Process is essential,
the following evolutionary model could be considered:
i. The Board of Governors will at an initial stage be the Euromed
Committee itself; the Board could be assisted for its decisions
by highly qualified personalities.
ii. The Director(s) of the Foundation (that is the Director (s)
of the co-ordinating body/ bodies) will report to the Euromed Committee
at regular intervals.
e) In general terms the funding of the Foundation should be devoted
to promoting in the most effective manner possible concrete projects;
expenditure on administration and institutional aspects should be
kept to an absolute minimum.
________________
Annex to ANNEX 2 - INDICATIVE LIST OF ACTIVITIES
a) Intellectual exchanges: The Foundation would contribute to the
debate and elaboration of the third chapter of the Barcelona Declaration
and notably the creation of a framework for dialogue and research
available to all strata of the academic fraternity, from school
teachers to education experts and academics to enable the furthering
of the dialogue on cultures, societies and civilisations in the
Euro-Mediterranean region. The focus should be on those who can
further disseminate the dialogue. Specifically, and as practical
examples, the Foundation could be responsible for activities such
as:
- organising seminars and conferences on Euro-Mediterranean relations
as a programme of continuous meetings, talks and publications,
- endowing research scholarships on Euro-Mediterranean relations,
the translation of books,
- launching cultural exchange programmes, in the event that this
were possible financially and operationally -
- co-ordinating with international organisations such as UNESCO
in order to create synergy and avoid unnecessary duplication of
projects and programmes,
- encouraging the production of textbooks on the heritage and values
of successive civilisations that have marked the history of the
region,
- encouraging participation in debates, meetings, exhibitions, seminars
and workshops of scholars, academics, universities, cultural ministries
and institutions, civil societies and universities,
- preparing programmes on cultures and arts of the Mediterranean
and encouraging TV channels on both shores of the Mediterranean
to broadcast them with subtitled translation,
- inviting Governments to encourage North-to-South and South-to-North
youth cultural tourism, with book and heritage exhibitions, and
traditional musical and theatre festivals which will be a suitable
environment to connect and build friendships,
- promoting the use of videoconferencing and other means of modern
technology to supplement mobility programmes,
- instituting an award system to recognise excellence and reward
due merit to individuals who have made substantial contributions
towards the development of Euro-Mediterranean relations.
b) Cultural and artistic exchanges: The Foundation would, taking
into account programmes and projects under MEDA and other donors,
promote cultural dialogue through additional programmes and/or projects
found to be relevant to a dialogue of cultures in the Mediterranean.
It would avoid duplication between existing activities including
those under MEDA, and would promote synergies among them. The Foundation
will notably support and promote the Action Programme for the Dialogue
between Cultures and Civilisations, adopted by the Foreign Ministers
of the Barcelona Process at their meeting in Valencia on 22-23 April,
2002, and the three themes of the Action Programme: youth, education
and the media.
The Foundation should also provide support for the development of
cultural and artistic knowledge between the 27 partners, by supporting
projects which encourage the mutual knowledge of cultures, intercultural
training, exchanges of practices, translations and publications.
In this context, the conclusions of the Stockholm workshop (first
half of 1998) should be taken into account; in particular, the Foundation
could support the following projects:
- The "Euromed Humanities" regional programme establishing
cooperation between institutions specialised in the study of and
research into Mediterranean societies and civilisations, which was
adopted in May 1998 and mentioned in the Valencia Action Plan;
- The project on books and translation, which was also adopted by
the Committee in November 1998 and could make a very useful contribution
to the dialogue between cultures;
- The organisation of the event "Year of the Mediterranean"
destined to promote the cultural, artistic and archeological heritage
of the Mediterranean countries.
- Encourage and undertake actions to promote the Mediterranean artisanal
heritage.
- The setting-up of Euro-Mediterranean networks of museums and of
libraries, for possible inclusion in the area of the Foundation's
activities devoted to cultural and artistic exchanges.
c) The visibility of the Barcelona Process: The Foundation would
aspire to disseminating the ideas of the Barcelona Process, complete
information on its activities and projects, and the establishment
of a "Euro-med label" as recognition for all those projects
in which it has a presence. These activities should be carried out
in close co-ordination with the future Euro-med regional programme
on Information and Communication called "Euromed Dialogue".
|